TechRater UK
APC BX1200MI and Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 UPS units side by side beside the headline APC vs Eaton UPS compared.
Computing

APC BX1200MI vs Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200: UPS Compared

The APC BX1200MI vs Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 comparison is a close one. Both are 1200VA UPS units with IEC outlets, a USB link for safe shutdown and a price aimed at home offices. However, they take different approaches to protecting your kit. APC uses a line-interactive design with AVR, while Eaton uses a standby design with a higher power rating and a much quieter body.

In short, this comparison helps you choose the right one for your PC, router or NAS.

Quick Verdict

  • Choose the APC BX1200MI if your power is patchy, because the AVR corrects dips and surges without using the battery, and all six outlets are battery-backed.
  • Choose the Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 USB IEC if you want a quieter, slimmer unit with a 750W rating, eight outlets and a longer half-load runtime.
  • Check stock first with either one: APC is replacing the BX1200MI with the BXR1200MI, and Eaton lists the Ellipse ECO 1200 as “to be discontinued”.

APC BX1200MI vs Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 Specifications

APC BX1200MI vs Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 USB IEC Specifications
Feature APC BX1200MI Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 USB IEC
Power Rating 1200VA / 650W 1200VA / 750W
Topology Line-interactive with AVR Standby (offline)
Battery-Backed Outlets 6x IEC C13 4x IEC C13
Surge-Only Outlets None 4x IEC C13
Waveform on Battery Stepped sine wave Check the manual
Battery Sealed lead-acid 2x 12V 7Ah sealed lead-acid
Runtime at Full Load About 1 minute About 1.5 minutes
Runtime at Half Load About 5 to 7 minutes About 10 minutes
Communication USB Type-B USB (HID compliant)
Software APC PowerChute Eaton UPS Companion
Extra Protection Ethernet data-line protection EcoControl outlets
Noise Level About 40 dB Under 25 dB at 1 m
Dimensions (H x W x D) 190 x 140 x 390 mm 305 x 81 x 312 mm
Weight 7.6 kg 6.7 kg
Rack Mounting No Optional ELRACK kit
Status Replaced by BXR1200MI Listed as to be discontinued

Power Protection and Voltage Regulation

The biggest difference in the APC BX1200MI vs Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 matchup is the design. The APC is line-interactive, so its AVR boosts or trims the mains within a wide input window of roughly 140 to 300V. As a result, it copes with brownouts and surges without switching to the battery, which saves wear and keeps your equipment running.

The Eaton is a standby unit. The mains passes straight through, and the battery steps in only when the supply fails or leaves the accepted window. Eaton lets you widen that window, but it has no AVR stage.

Our take: the APC is the better choice for a house with an unreliable supply.

Outlets and Power Rating

Here the two split the honours. The APC gives you six battery-backed IEC outlets, so every socket keeps working in a power cut. The Eaton has eight sockets in total, but only four are battery-backed, and the other four give surge protection only.

However, the Eaton carries a higher real-power rating of 750W against the APC’s 650W. For example, a PC with a modest graphics card and a monitor is more likely to stay inside the Eaton’s limit. Always add up your actual load before you buy either one.

Our take: pick the APC for more backed-up sockets, or the Eaton for more headroom.

Battery Runtime

Neither unit is built for long outages. The APC manages about a minute at full load and about five to seven minutes at half load. The Eaton manages about a minute and a half at full load and about ten minutes at half load.

Therefore, the Eaton has the edge, particularly at lighter loads. In practice, a typical PC and router draw far less than half the rating, so both give you enough time for a safe shutdown. Both use sealed lead-acid batteries, which need replacing every few years.

Our take: the Eaton wins on runtime, though the gap matters little for a safe shutdown.

Noise, Size and Design

The Eaton is the quieter and slimmer of the two. It runs at under 25 dB at one metre, whereas the APC is about 40 dB. It stands tall at 305 mm but only 81 mm wide, so it fits into narrow gaps and can mount in a rack with the optional ELRACK kit.

The APC is a squat, wider box at 190 x 140 x 390 mm and weighs 7.6 kg. Also, it has LED indicators only, with no LCD screen, and so does the Eaton.

Our take: the Eaton suits a quiet desk or a tight cupboard better.

Monitoring, Software and Extras

Both connect to your PC over USB, and Windows can read each as a battery. APC offers PowerChute for safe shutdown, while Eaton offers UPS Companion with shutdown and energy metering. Besides this, the APC adds Ethernet data-line protection, which helps if your router or network switch sits on the same line.

Eaton adds EcoControl outlets, which cut power to idle peripherals when your main PC switches off. This can save up to 25% energy.

Our take: it’s a tie, because each adds one useful extra.

Which Is Best for You?

  • Unreliable mains supply: the APC BX1200MI, thanks to its AVR.
  • Six backed-up devices: the APC BX1200MI.
  • Quiet bedroom or living room setup: the Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200.
  • Higher-power PC: the Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200, with its 750W rating.
  • Energy-saving peripherals: the Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200, with EcoControl.
  • Network gear on the same line: the APC BX1200MI, with Ethernet protection.

Conclusion

The APC BX1200MI vs Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200 contest has no outright winner. In short, the APC wins on protection, with AVR and six backed-up outlets. The Eaton wins on rating, runtime and silence, with 750W, about ten minutes at half load and under 25 dB.

If you live somewhere with unreliable power, buy the APC. If you want a quiet, slim unit for a desktop PC, buy the Eaton. Before you decide, check availability and the current replacement models on the Schneider Electric and Eaton sites.

Which would you pick? Tell us in the comments.

Questions People Ask

Is the APC BX1200MI Better Than the Eaton Ellipse ECO 1200?

It depends on your needs. The APC is better for poor mains because of its AVR and six backed-up outlets. The Eaton is better for quiet running and a higher 750W rating.

Which UPS Has the Longer Runtime?

The Eaton. It manages about ten minutes at half load, against about five to seven minutes for the APC.

Which Is Quieter?

The Eaton. It runs at under 25 dB at one metre, while the APC is about 40 dB.

Which Has More Battery-Backed Outlets?

The APC, with six. The Eaton has eight sockets, but only four are battery-backed.

Does Either UPS Have a Pure Sine Wave Output?

The APC outputs a stepped sine wave on battery. Check the Eaton manual for its battery waveform if your equipment needs a pure sine wave.

What Is AVR and Why Does It Matter?

Automatic voltage regulation corrects low or high mains without using the battery. As a result, the battery lasts longer and your equipment sees steadier power.

Can Either UPS Run a Gaming PC?

Only a modest one. The APC is rated at 650W and the Eaton at 750W, so a PC with a powerful graphics card may exceed both. Add up the real power draw first.

Are the Batteries Replaceable?

Yes, on both. They are sealed lead-acid batteries that typically need replacing every few years.

Will Either Work With Windows Safe Shutdown?

Yes. Each has a USB link that Windows can read as a battery, and each has its own software for safe shutdown.

Are These UPS Models Being Discontinued?

Both are on the way out. APC is replacing the BX1200MI with the BXR1200MI, and Eaton lists the Ellipse ECO 1200 as “to be discontinued”. Check stock and spare batteries before you buy.

Related posts

Wireless Routers With New Device Connection Notifications

TechRater

Asustor AS6602T NAS Server Review

TechRater

HP Poly Focus 6 Series: Wireless Freedom With No Interruptions

TechRater